Kategorien
Antifaschismus Recht Wissenschaft

Contesting the Far-Right: A Psychoanalytic and Feminist Critical Theory Approach

By Claudia Leeb

Contesting the Far-Right: A Psychoanalytic and Feminist Critical Theory Approach (Columbia University Press, New Directions in Critical Theory series, 2024) examines far-right recruitment tactics in the United States and Austria, where people discontented with the status quo have turned to far-right parties and movements that further cement capitalism’s adverse effects. I show that psychoanalytic theory, early Frankfurt School Critical Theory, and feminist and decolonial thought provide analytical tools to explain this apparent contradiction in psychological terms.

While I consider psychoanalytic theory as central to understanding far-right propaganda techniques, the rise of the far right today is not only a psychological problem. It is also a socioeconomic and political problem. However, insofar as the far right’s destructive objective aims contradict the material and other interests of people whose support they aim to win, people do not join the far right because of rational economic or other self-interests, and the far right cannot win the support of the masses through rational arguments.

Instead, as Theodor W. Adorno noted, fascist propaganda “must necessarily be deflected from discursive thinking; it must be oriented psychologically, and has to mobilize irrational, unconscious, regressive processes” in the masses to win their support (Adorno 2002). I draw on Sigmund Freud and psychoanalytically inspired texts by Adorno to explain how far-right propaganda techniques mobilize unconscious and regressive processes in subjects, which makes them support the far right’s destructive goals.


„Objective conditions of suffering generate subjective forms of suffering.“

However, I go beyond Freud and Adorno in significant ways, allowing me better to explain the dialectics between the psychological and the socio-economic. To begin with, I show that we must attend to questions of subjectivity to grasp how far-right propaganda techniques become effective. I start from the psychoanalytic assumption that subjects are fundamentally nonwhole, which generates anxieties and desires (the desire to achieve “wholeness”) in subjects. Drawing on Karl Marx, I show that far-right propaganda techniques are particularly effective in precarity capitalism because precarity capitalism heightens subjects’ anxieties and desires around their nonwhole subjectivities.

The reason for this is the prevalence of the fetish of “success” in capitalist societies, which implies (classed, raced, and gendered) economic, interpersonal, and bodily “success” standards for subjects living in such societies. However, objective conditions of suffering in precarity capitalism (the threat of declassing, the inability to get or keep a job, exploitation, alienation, and isolation) make it difficult, if not impossible, for most subjects to live up to such standards. As a result, objective conditions of suffering generate subjective forms of suffering, which people experience in the form of heightened anxieties and desires around their nonwhole subjectivities.

Psychologically oriented far-right propaganda techniques are effective in capitalist societies because they fulfill people’s growing desire to reach an impossible wholeness on an illusory level. Meanwhile, the objective conditions of suffering in capitalism that generated people’s heightened anxieties and desires around their non-whole subjectivities remain intact or become further entrenched through the far right. Since the far right does nothing to change the objective conditions of suffering in precarity capitalism, the followers remain vulnerable to far-right propaganda techniques that allow them to feel as “whole” subjects again.

Patriarchal and white society expects particularly white men from all classes to live up to the fetish of economic, interpersonal, and bodily success – it expects them to have or obtain well-paying jobs, working relationships, and virile bodies. Such a view results from European settler colonialism, which invented the idea of “race” and the prejudice that whites, especially white men, are the “superior race” who ought to be on the top of the economic hierarchy and have well-paying jobs, while all other “inferior races” ought to do devalued, low-paying or free jobs for them. However, in precarity capitalism, it has become more and more difficult for white men from all classes, despite their varying privileges, to live up to such expectations. Therefore, they experience heightened anxieties around their non-whole subjectivities and a growing desire to become a „whole“ man, which makes them particularly vulnerable to far-right recruitment tactics that prey on anxieties and desires around people’s non-whole subjectivities.

In psychoanalytic thought, the ego initially believes itself to be perfect and “whole” (which is the narcissistic state). However, when confronted with societal demands the ego cannot fulfill, it splits part of itself off—the ego ideal. The ego ideal is composed of people’s ideal view of themselves and what they aspire to be like. In today’s capitalist societies, the ego ideal results from the fetish of „success.“ Since most people cannot live up to their ego ideal in precarity capitalism, they experience a sharp tension between the ego and the ego ideal with accompanying feelings of failure and anxiety.
The psychologically oriented far-right propaganda techniques are effective because they allow people to undo the tension between their ego and their ego ideal, and puts them in a sleep and dream state, where they feel, in a hallucinatory fashion, as if they are “successful” on an economic, interpersonal, and bodily level. Such a state generates an ecstatic high in them, which allows them to get rid of feelings of failure and anxiety. At the same time, the objective conditions of capitalism that generated their feelings of non-wholeness remain intact.

Furthermore, the propaganda techniques that allow the followers to undo the tension between their ego and their ego ideal also put their super-ego, which is the mental instance in us that keeps our repressed libidinal and aggressive drives in check, temporarily (or for prolonged periods) out of action – as a result, the followers can now obtain their repressed aggressive and libidinal drives and their repressed racist and sexist attitudes in their conscious, which the far right can now redirect towards its chosen foes.

„We all suffer in precarity capitalism and struggle to varying degrees with feelings of non-wholeness.“

Ego ideal replacement establishes a libidinal or love bond between the mass followers and the leader. Furthermore, the followers‘ shared libidinal bond with the leader allows them to identify with each other, which unifies the mass followers and does away with lingering feelings of envy (as they all share the same love object) and hostility between them. However, since there are few positive content available in far-right ideology, and positive libido is solely invested in the leader figure only, far-right propaganda techniques also utilize negative content to unify the mass, such as their shared hatred against a particular person or group, which are in today’s societies increasingly immigrants and migrants.

In a far-right mass with an identifiable leader (such as the Trump mass or the Austrian Freedom Party), the followers replace their ego ideal with the idealized leader figure to undo the split between their ego and their ego ideal and feel whole again on a subjective level. In contrast, in a far-right mass without an identifiable leader figure (such as the alt-right in the United States and the identitarian movement in Europe), the movement’s use of specific propaganda techniques (such as racist and sexist jokes) fulfills a similar function.      


About the Author

Claudia Leeb (she/her) is a feminist political theorist and Professor at Washington State University. Drawing on psychoanalysis, early Frankfurt School Critical Theory, and feminist thought, her research explores how power shapes political subjects and what makes the far right appealing today. Her latest book, Contesting the Far Right, was published by Columbia University Press in 2024.

Schreibe einen Kommentar